Revisiting a Relevant P/CP Discussion: Will JS7 to JGR YZ450 Work?

I launched MS Word(believe it) on my laptop today for the first time in a while apparently, because I was presented with the Point/Counter-Point debate between Matthes and I titled "Will the JGR/James Stewart signing work?".

I was intrigued to see who held the apparent upperhand in the debate, 6 races into the SX series. It's still a good read and very relevant now with some proof positive behind it. Specifically I'm going to go all DV on you here and point out how accurate my initial reasoning is for the signing being a gamble.

Check it out